Sources reviewed on 12 September 2026.
Compare direct-sale fees, PDF protection, and membership needs. Your choice depends on product prices, buyer location, and whether you need recurring billing.
No platform wins every need. Match features and plan limits to your workflow.
For low-priced products, account for the fixed charge as well as the percentage.
If you need recurring memberships now, check the s.id feature status before moving customers.
Example: 10 direct sales at US$10 produce US$100 gross. The platform component is 10% × US$100 + 10 × US$0.50 = US$15. This is not the total deduction; check applicable processing, tax, and payout charges.
Use matching order counts, gross sales, currencies, billing periods, and payout frequency. Total cost = subscription + platform fees + processing + payouts + applicable taxes/conversion. The s.id calculator estimates components based on your plan; check the final transaction breakdown.
The s.id PDF watermark depends on your plan and helps identify copies; it does not guarantee protection against resharing. Recurring memberships are coming soon; check the feature catalog before choosing a plan.
Values come from the public sources listed below this table.
| Feature & sources | s.id Shop | Gumroad |
|---|---|---|
| Platform fees | Free plan without a monthly subscription; service percentage depends on the plan. See active rates in the s.id calculator. | No monthly subscription; direct sales 10% + US$0.50, Discover 30%. |
| Product types | Ebooks, templates, presets, and digital access; features depend on your plan. | Digital products, courses, and memberships. |
| PDF watermark | Plan-based PDF watermarking helps identify copies; it does not guarantee protection against resharing. | PDF stamping available; buyer email is stamped on the first page. |
| Recurring memberships | Recurring memberships are coming soon. One-time digital access is not automatic subscription billing. | Memberships available. |
Official references for table rows and fee details. Check plan, region, effective date, and document scope; selection guidance and worked examples use the assumptions stated.
Questions before you choose
Start on the Free plan, check available features, and prepare your first digital product. The Shop service fee may not include payment gateway, settlement, withdrawal, or applicable tax charges. The latest details are shown before confirming a transaction or subscription.
